Book - 2001
Average Rating:
Rate this:
This compelling successor to Garnethill, which won the prestigious John Creasy Memorial Award for Best First Crime Novel in 1998, returns to Glasgow's grimmer precincts and the untidy life of Maureen O'Donnell. It also again pulls Maureen into a grisly case of murder -- this time of Ann Harris, who had been nursing two broken ribs and reeking of alcohol when she'd visited Maureen's office at the women's shelter two weeks before her mutilated body was washed up by the Thames hundreds of miles away.

Eager to quit Glasgow for a spell and escape her own problems, Maureen travels to London to search out the circumstances surrounding Ann's brutal death -- and soon finds herself treacherously out of her depth. As Maureen strives in desperation to piece together Ann's last days in order to save herself from a similar fate, the suspense ratchets up and Denise Mina secures her place among the top-ranking writers of hard-boiled crime fiction at work today.

Publisher: New York : Carroll & Graf, 2001
Edition: 1st Carroll & Graf ed
ISBN: 9780786708383
Characteristics: 364 p. ; 24 cm


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment

May 31, 2018

Authentic content presented in a realist style. I enjoyed this narrative because it spoke to the real world and did not try to reproduce some "winning formula" like the USA sourced perchance for the "hardboiled detective" or the impossible to sort out puzzle "who done it".

Nov 02, 2016

The second book in the Garnethill series

Aug 11, 2015

In this followup to Garnethill, Maureen O'Donnell, having lost her job due to investigating her boyfriend's death and now working in a women's shelter, hears about the brutal murder of a former shelter resident. After visiting the husband she decides he is too passive to have beaten and murdered the woman so she goes down to London to investigate. Maureen's own problems continue to haunt her: the return of her abusive father, her alcoholic mother, unfriendly siblings, nosy cops, deteriorating friendship with Leslie and dismay at brother Liam's former occupation. As she delves into the seamy side of the seamiest parts of London she finds herself in danger but somehow also getting stronger. She comes back to Glasgow clearer about who she is and what she wants. Fantastic characters abound in this gritty novel.

May 19, 2014

Set in Glasgow. Raw and gritty but with compassion. Superb. This is book 2 of the Garnethill Trilogy. Best to read the series in order to make the best sense of things: 1) Garnethill; 2) Exile; 3) Resolution.

Dec 06, 2013

An excellent read and just what I always expect from this great mystery writer whose characterizations are just as strong as her plot lines.

emily8 Apr 29, 2013

my second book of mina's - what great promise - hope she writes very long time - recommended - let go of your prejudices and be part of her writing experience... Life is too short, enjoy many good authors...

Feb 19, 2013

My second Mina book, and... the comment is the same: too much inessentials. These books are more about family matters than a mystery or a thriller. After reading half the book, you begin to get bore and wish the end would come quickly. I mean the book is a muddle of dullness. Nothing happens quickly
and again too much do about nothing is not a good way to write a book.

Sep 06, 2010

Not my kind of book. Dark and depressing characters.


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at WCLS

To Top